Skip to main content
Back to Resources
Features

Comparing Current vs Renewal Plans

When you quote a medical renewal, Monark works in two steps. First you confirm the plans the group is on today, so Monark can price them at today's rates. Then you map each of those plans to a renewal plan and add alternative options. The comparison page shows the group's Current cost next to the Renewal and each option, with the change versus current.

This guide covers the renewal mode of the instant medical quote. New-business quotes use the standard plan selection described in Obtaining Quotes.


Opening a Renewal Quote

  1. Open the Proposal and go to the Quotes tab
  2. Open the Medical instant quote

The quote page opens on the Renewal Quote tab. Switch to Virgin Quote for a new-business quote. A saved quote always reopens on its own type.

The page shows two steps: Step 1 — Confirm current plans and Step 2 — Renewal plans. Step 2 stays locked ("Confirm your current plans above first.") until Step 1 is saved or skipped.


Step 1 — Confirm Current Plans

Step 1 records the plan each group of members has today. Monark prices those plans at the prior plan year's rates. That is what fills the Current column on the comparison page.

The current plan lines come from the census Medical Plan Name column, one line per distinct plan name. Clean up plan names first: two spellings of the same plan become two lines.

Fill or skip

  • Fill current plans opens the step
  • Skip current plans goes straight to Step 2. The comparison then shows the renewal and alternatives only, with no Current column. You can add current plans later with Change current plans

Set the dates

Enter the Current effective date and the Renewal effective date. The current date must be on or before the renewal date.

Pick each current plan

You are browsing the prior year's plans (the year the group is covered for now), not the renewal year. Premiums aren't shown here; they come from pricing once you save.

  • Click Set current plan on a line to open the plan browser for that line, or tick several lines and pick one plan for all of them
  • Or click Smart Suggest to fill every line. In this step Smart Suggest keeps to the carrier named in the census plan name. If that carrier has no matching plan, the line is left unset with a note such as "No 2025 Aetna plans found — select manually."
  • Each picked line shows a badge: Plan code verified, or Matched by name — confirm when the match came from the plan name only. Check those

Click Save current plans. The step collapses to a one-line summary, for example "Current plan rates ready — the comparison will show a Current column." Use Change current plans to review or change the picks.

When current plans can't be priced

  • No plans for that year. If the prior year's catalog is empty for the group's state, the step says so, for example "2025 Texas plans aren't available." Use Skip current plans. If the list simply failed to load, click Retry
  • No rates for that year. If Ideon publishes no rates for the prior plan year, you can still save the picks to record what the group has today, but the comparison shows a placeholder instead of a priced Current column
  • A pick wasn't priced. If a picked plan wasn't priced for the current effective date, the step asks you to re-pick that line
  • Members born after the current date are left out of current pricing, and the step lists them. They weren't on the plan then, and Ideon returns no rates when they are included

Step 2 — Renewal Plans

Step 2 is one grid: a Current column with one row per current plan line, then Renewal, then any Option columns you add.

Map each line to its renewal plan

For each row, choose the plan those members move to at renewal:

  • Click the row's cell in the Renewal column to open the plan browser, filter it (carrier, plan type, metal level, deductible, infertility rider) and pick a plan
  • Or click Smart Suggest to fill every empty cell. For the Renewal column it:
    • Keeps the group on the same plan when the carrier still offers it for the renewal year
    • Otherwise prefers the same carrier. If the carrier isn't sold in the line's market (for example direct vs CalChoice) but its insurer is sold in another market, it picks that insurer there
    • Never changes metal tier. With no same-tier plan, the cell is left empty
    • Then ranks by network size, deductible and primary care copay
  • Undo steps back through your mapping changes, including a Smart Suggest

The card counts down: "k of M plans remaining. All plans must be mapped to continue." When every row is mapped it shows All plans mapped! and Compare & Price Plans.

Current rows are labelled Carrier - Plan from the plan you confirmed in Step 1. Plans sold through CalChoice or Covered California show the exchange as the carrier, with the insurer in muted text (for example CalChoice · Anthem).

Plans with no current plan behind them

  • Add Plan under the Renewal column adds a plan that's new at renewal. Its row is labelled New at renewal
  • Add Plan under the Current column adds a Not enrolled line. Choose waived employees to price on the renewal plans; their dependents come with them. Their premiums are estimated from the plan's age curve, and the census isn't changed. Once the line has members, click it to change who's on it. If one of them later gets a plan in the census, the line says they were removed from it

Add alternative options

Click Add option to add another column (Option 1, Option 2 and so on). Each option is a full set of plans for every row, for example a move to another carrier or to leaner plans. Map its cells the same way, or use Smart Suggest, which fills option cells with a different carrier per column, again keeping each row's metal tier. Remove an option from its column header.

An option can reuse a plan that the Renewal column or another option already uses. For example, a "Kaiser / Blue Shield" option can keep the renewal's own Kaiser plans on the Kaiser lines. Each column is still priced for its own members and its own base plan.

Options you haven't renamed are numbered by position (Option 1, Option 2 and so on), on screen and in exports. If you remove an option, the rest renumber so there's no gap. An option you've named keeps its name.

If a plan in an option is no longer available in this quote, its cell says "No longer in this quote — pick another."


Reading the Comparison

Compare & Price Plans opens the comparison for the Current, Renewal and option columns. Prices appear once every column is ready.

  • Premiums count assigned members only. Each plan is priced for the members mapped to it. Waived members are left out unless you placed them on the Not enrolled line
  • Totals. Each column shows its Total / month, split into Employer pays and Employees pay. Premium cells show the total only; the employer and employee split is in those rows and in the member breakdown
  • Change vs current. With a priced Current column, each column shows its change versus current. Switch between % and $ with the Change vs current toggle
  • Benefit focus. Use the benefit filter to hide benefit categories you don't need to compare. It changes the view only
  • Pinning. Pin up to 3 plans to keep them in view while you scroll
  • If current-year rates aren't available yet, the Current column shows a placeholder; the renewal and options are unaffected

Back to All Plans returns to the two steps.


Contributions

The Contribution Configuration panel above the table has two tabs:

  • Current — what the Employer contributes today. It prices the Current column
  • Renewal — the contribution you're modeling for renewal. Until you set one, it follows the Current tab

On the Renewal tab, scenario pills apply common cases in one click:

| Scenario | What it does | | ------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Current | Applies today's contribution structure to every option | | Employer absorbs increase | Holds employee deductions at today's level; the Employer pays the rest | | Employee absorbs increase | Holds the Employer at today's dollars; employees pay the rest |

The absorb scenarios lock the rows ("click the selected scenario again to edit them"). Editing a row yourself switches to a custom configuration. Contribution types, job classes, caps and base plan pricing work as described in Employer Contributions.

Each renewal quote keeps its own Current and Renewal contributions. Changing them on one quote doesn't change another, and a new quote starts without contributions from earlier quotes.

The panel has no Save button of its own: Save Quote saves both tabs.


Saving a Renewal Quote

Click Save Quote, name the quote (for example "Straight Renewal" or "Buy-Down Option") and add an optional description and notes. It saves the plans, every option, and both contribution tabs together.

  • After saving, the button reads Saved. Any later change turns it to Save changes, and the tab you changed is marked unsaved
  • If a contribution row is incomplete, Save Quote is held and names the tab to fix
  • Leaving the page with unsaved changes asks you to confirm (Leave without saving)

On the Proposal's Quotes tab, a saved renewal quote shows its total and Employer/employee split.

If you change Step 2 after saving

If you change the plans in Step 2 after saving, the saved quote is marked Unsaved changes, and its cost on the Quotes tab reads Out of date: "Plans changed in Step 2 after this quote was saved. Open Compare & Price and save to update it." Until you save it again, it can't be added to a proposal or exported. Click Edit quote, open Compare & Price Plans, and save.

If the quote is already in a sent proposal, see Sending Proposals for updating the proposal.


Best Practices

  • Clean up the census first. The current lines, and who lands on each plan, come from the census Medical Plan Name column
  • Confirm current plans whenever you can. Without them there's no Current column and no change-versus-current figures
  • Check every "Matched by name — confirm" line and every Smart Suggest pick, especially carriers with several similarly named plans
  • Keep options few and distinct. Two or three clearly different options (straight renewal, buy-down, alternative carrier) are easier for an Employer to decide between

Next Steps